Planet Lean: The Official online magazine of the Lean Global Network
Durward Sobek shares a few valuable insights on LPPD

Durward Sobek shares a few valuable insights on LPPD

Durward Sobek
July 8, 2016

90-SECOND Q&A – At a recent summit, our editor Roberto Priolo sat down with Durward Sobek to discuss design thinking, obstacles to the application of lean in product and process development, and why LPPD in services is a bit different.


Interviewee: Durward Sobek, Professor and Program Coordinator of Industrial & Management Systems Engineering, Montana State University


Roberto Priolo: In your experience studying organizations that are trying to apply lean product and process development principles, what seems to be the biggest hurdle they face?

Durward Sobek: There are two main issues that come up a lot. The first one is the difficulty to understand where to start – and there are many different ideas on that. The second one is an obstacle every lean practitioner knows well: the struggle to get management to buy in.

RP: What dimension does LPPD add to the benefits a company can get from traditional applications of lean thinking?

DS: It’s an application of an alternative management approach to a different kind of work: knowledge creation. Some of the questions LPPD can help us to answer include: “How do we look at this type of work and say what’s adding value and what’s not” “How do we teach people problem solving and have them align towards a common direction in this area where a lot of the work is not visible?” or “How do we assess quality?” This is a very challenging environment, but there is no doubt LPPD pushes lean thinking to a new level.

RP: What are the differences between applying lean to the development of a product and that of a service?

DS: There is quite a bit of difference. The second P in LPPD stands for process (as in manufacturing process) and we put it in there to remind ourselves that if we focus exclusively on the product and pay little attention to how we deliver it, we only get half of the picture. Lean is a system!

The difference with designing a service is that the customer is much more involved in the creation of that process. In the service industry, we are almost talking about co-creation of the product with the customer, and the concurrent development of the product and the process nearly in real time.

RP: What is the relationship between LPPD and design thinking?

DS: Design thinking is a great approach. Interestingly, not much in it is particularly new, but I must say that the community has found a very engaging and fun way to package and teach it.

As an approach, it is very consistent with what we believe in: the idea of really engaging and understanding your user and starting by really understanding what they consider to be value-added is very much in line with traditional lean thinking.

The same is true for their way of looking at lots of ideas and running quick experiments to learn about them so that you can make intelligent decisions.

There are also a few differences, of course. To me, the most evident is that design thinking is not quite as comprehensive as lean. In particular, it doesn’t address the issue of scalability – at present, it is quite difficult to apply design thinking to large R&D departments. I am sure that if they were to tackle that problem, design thinkers would reach conclusions similar to ours – actually, it would be very interesting to bring them in and compare ideas.

RP: You recently participated in the European edition of the LPPDE event. What is the state of adoption of LPPD principles in Europe compared to the United States?

DS: LPPD adoption in the US and Europe is pretty comparable, even though Europe might be focusing a bit more on visual management than the US does – which is triggered by the Scandinavian countries.


THE INTERVIEWEE

Durward Sobek photograph

Durward K. Sobek II is a Professor and Program Coordinator of Industrial and Management Systems Engineering at Montana State University. He has been researching lean product development and lean healthcare for nearly two decades. Durward is co-founder of the not-for-profit Lean Product and Process Development Exchange, Inc. whose mission is to share and expand the body of knowledge around lean product and process development. He is a frequent presenter, and has co-authored Lean Product and Process Development, 2nd edition with Allen C. Ward and Understanding A3 Thinking: A Critical Component of Toyota's PDCA Management System.


Read more

The iron law of scale-up
October 24, 2019
The iron law of scale-up

FEATURE – As our social systems grow, we need an effective way to manage them. This makes bureaucracies an inescapable part of life for our society and businesses. But how can we mitigate their negative effects?

Continue reading
Predictable vs unpredictable work
February 6, 2020
Predictable vs unpredictable work

FEATURE – It is a common misconception that our work is too unpredictable to fit into a standardized approach. The author debunks this myth.

Continue reading
Lean healthcare on the front lines
March 30, 2020
Lean healthcare on the front lines

FEATURE – Our coverage of the Covid-19 emergency continues with an article discussing how lean healthcare principles can support and protect the professionals at the front line of this war.

Continue reading
One-time customer, lifelong customer
January 10, 2023
One-time customer, lifelong customer

FEATURE – We start the new year with a reminder to put customers first, always. It is they who make our business and keep our lean initiatives true, says the author.

Continue reading

Read more

No items found.